Inside: Looking for an alternative to time out? Learn how “time to yourself” can change your child’s way of thinking and stop negative behavior without punishments!
I don’t care how sweet your kids are…at some point they ALL misbehave.
Mine included!
So how do you stop the bad behavior effectively without yelling or losing your temper?
Because that doesn’t really work…and usually leaves you feeling pretty crappy too.
One of the more popular methods of disciplining children is “time out,” which involves sending a child who misbehaves to a designated location for a set amount of time as punishment.
While I don’t think this is necessarily a bad thing, I have found an alternative to time out that has proven much more effective for us.
How “Time to Yourself” Works
Our alternative to punishments like time out is what I’ve dubbed “time to yourself.” Here’s a breakdown of how it works:
1. Stop Everything
Whatever we are doing, I stop immediately and we deal with the situation in that very moment. Whether we are at home or in public, I acknowledge the undesirable behavior NOW, rather than saying “we will deal with this later” or “we will talk about it when we get home.”
If you wait until later, your child has already moved on in their mind. I know that the situation will be most effectively handled if it is done in the present.
2. Get Their Attention
To do this, I talk in a low voice so my daughter has to get quiet to hear me.
I only raise my voice in what I would consider an emergency situation where I need instant action (for example, if she were about to run across a busy parking lot without looking).
Otherwise, I get down to her level so we have direct eye contact and speak in a calm, even, firm voice. She knows that I mean business.
Yelling or getting angry when not absolutely necessary can cause a child to recoil in fear and miss the message you’re trying to give.
3. Time to Yourself
Once I explain why the behavior in question is unacceptable, I remove her from the situation.
I’ll say something along the lines of, “I am going to let you have some time to yourself to think about your actions and make a choice if you would like to be around us.”
Why “Time to Yourself” is Different Than “Time Out”
“Time to yourself” is similar to “time out” in that it involves a child going to his or her room.
However, “time to yourself” is different from “time out” in that it is not presented as a punishment, but rather, a choice.
I explain to my daughter that she has two options:
- Find a more positive way to interact with us -OR-
- Have alone time in your room
With this alternative to traditional punishments, it is still very clear that a certain behavior or action was unacceptable. However, there is NO shaming and kids feel like they have some control over things.
Because when kids feel out of control, they tend to overreact to feel like they can control something – even if that something is getting themselves in more trouble.
You can see how that would be counterproductive!
The “where”
I chose my girls’ room as the location for “time to yourself” because it is a safe place, where they won’t be on the defensive and can instead constructively work on a way to self-regulate.
This is not about shaming or humiliating for “bad behavior,” but rather removing the child from a negative situation and giving them the space and the tools to change their course of action.
The “when”
There is no time requirement — I allow my daughters to take as much or as little time as needed. Sometimes they are ready to come out within just a few minutes.
On other occasions, my oldest especially, will spend thirty minutes to an hour in her room, resting or reading.
On those days, she obviously needed to recharge and not have to be around people for a while.
When she emerges, my daughter is calm, happy, and eager to please. Sometimes she has even made her bed or cleaned her room while she was in there, without being asked!
The “why”
We parents start to get a little crazy when we don’t have “me time” for a while, so it makes sense that kids would too.
Kids are always surrounded by others, both at school and at home, to the point where it starts to get overwhelming for some. However, kids don’t always know how to vocalize their need for space.
While bad behavior itself isn’t acceptable, this could be your child’s way of showing you that they need a break from the stress of socialization.
Discipline can be a hot-button topic among parents, and there is no one-size-fits-all solution for every family.
However, this alternative to time out, or “time to yourself,” has been a very effective tool for helping my daughters to cope with stress and find positive ways to express themselves around others.
Recommended reading:
Happy You, Happy Family: Find Your Personal Recipe for Happiness in the Chaos of Parenting Life by Kelly Holmes
Kelly is a friend and colleague whose work has changed the lives of countless families. Her new e-book shares the recipe to:
- Stop feeling overwhelmed. Get a handle on the swirling chaos of to-do items and appointments and “should”s in your head.
- Set yourself up for a happy day, every day. Find out the ingredients you need in your day in order to become your happiest self.
- Catch yourself before you lose your cool. Learn what to do when you lose your patience with a temper-taming toolkit of proven tools to get you back on track.
- Heal after the storm. For the days when you do lose your cool, you’ll get the exact steps to flush the bad mojo from your body and repair the relationship with your child (or your partner).
Grab your copy of the e-book for Kindle, Nook, or iBooks:
More of our most popular parenting posts:
The Secret to Ending Conflict with your Tween
How to Stop Temper Tantrums in Seconds
For more positive parenting ideas from REAL moms, follow my Positive Parenting Tips board on Pinterest:
Follow Stacey @ The Soccer Mom Blog’s board Positive Parenting Tips on Pinterest.
- Chocolate Chip Cookies with Raspberries - November 23, 2020
- Slow Cooker Garlic Mashed Potatoes - November 19, 2020
- Easy Nutella Fudge Recipe - November 16, 2020
Lorna says
Thank you for posting this, I’ve been looking for an alternative that removes my daughter from the situation effectively. My girl is 3yrs old and my son is about two, they are constantly going at each other and nothing we have tried has worked. My son is too young understand most consequences and my daughter doesn’t seem to correct her behavior with any tactic.
Stacey aka the Soccer Mom says
I’m so glad you found this helpful Lorna!
Alina says
Just what I needed to deal worth my almost 3 year old. Thanks for wiring this, it does sound like is coming from he heart
Stacey aka the Soccer Mom says
Thank you for letting me know you liked it Alina!
OneCaringMom says
Thank you! I love this. There are so many days that my son is just so overwhelmed and needs to have some time to recharge. And he always responds so much better about his behavior if we have a productive conversation and he can chill out.I think this is a great alternative to time-out.
Stacey aka the Soccer Mom says
I’m glad to hear that this simple strategy works for your family too 🙂
Brie says
I love this approach! Thank you so much for this helpful article.
Judy says
Just wondering where do they go when in public if their room isn’t an option?
Stacey aka the Soccer Mom says
In our case, this behavior happens less often in public – tweens are pretty self conscious about what other people think. But there have been a couple times where we’ve gone to sit in the car while the rest of the family finishes dinner, etc. I supervise so no one is alone in the car, but it is generally quiet time.